Skip to main content

Is improvement a straight line?

A question I am often asked is this - "am I on the right path?"

This question is usually posed by someone who is going through a period of change and feels that they aren't doing it right, because the actions don't seem to be following some prescribed / perceived route...

I've been there, and I'm sure that you have too.

I don't think the path is straight, even the good projects bend and wane a little.

I touched on this issue in my book 'On Time Delivery', here is an excerpt:


Polishing Gems

I once heard a Chinese proverb 'you can’t polish a gem without friction' and I like to think that some of the conversations (to put mildly) that I experienced were simply that, an essential rub in order to create something better.
The first real friction I encountered was when it became common knowledge that I had improvement plans and that I intended to implement these plans. Previously plans had been drawn up for similar things by other people, but never acted upon or followed through... mine just hadn't been written up at that point.
Now that I knew how bad the delivery performance was I wanted to understand how we got ourselves into that position. Further to this I was curious why we had never got out of this position during the four years to which the data related. From looking at the split of work going through the business and our near steady order book value overall, it was fairly obvious that some departments were overloaded and others were not. We only re-allocated labour periodically to minimise some departments being slack whilst others were stretched.
From asking around I came to the simple conclusion that our order book was loaded on guesswork and it depended upon the turnover figure currently loaded for a particular month, irrespective of whether the product mix was right or labour levels were available. Finding out this information got me into a whole load of unpleasant conversations about minding my own business and being a meddler. Telling people it was my business didn’t help matters, but I wasn’t in the mood for pleasing certain people in the business.
One particular day my mind returned to another point in production that was bugging me, the loading of the process vessels. On my whiteboard I drew out the vessels, and did some very basic calculations about the throughput in each department before the processing stage and came up with a simple solution to the capacity overload being experienced in the Assembly Shop.
One of my current antagonists entered my office and watched me for a moment at the whiteboard before asking me what I was doing. After explaining my diagram I was told just how far off the mark I was and that this problem had been solved by someone with a degree in the 1970s. I felt it was only right to counter with my take on things but was left talking to myself as the other person left the room mid-sentence.
We used to get on well too...
The next day the same person came back to my office and quizzed me about my credentials and my previous work experience. I explained what I wanted to do, and how I wanted us to work together to achieve these goals. I got very little reply to this before they once again left my office.

Later that week there was a shock announcement that the business was going to request ten people to take voluntary redundancy. Our financial figures weren't stacking up and we needed to ‘lose some bodies’.
After the meeting my boss came to visit me, the other Production Manager left the room.
I was informed that a couple of members of staff were going to go, including the person who had criticised my process vessels idea and, one of my direct colleagues, the Production Planner. Due to a lack of resource going forward I was then informed that I would be responsible for the planning and scheduling of the orders going through the factory.
The boss left and I sat back in my chair to contemplate what I had been told. On one hand I had the opportunity to take control of a part of the business process that I didn't think worked as well as it could. I hadn't really thought through the other hand at this point...

Learning Points

- Don’t lose sight of the problems you have in your business, capture them for later if you can’t deal with them right now.
- If something doesn't work, keep it in your sights until you fix it, or you work out how to fix it.
- Most problems can be solved with simple solutions. If your solution isn’t simple (and really effective) keep working on it.



If you feel like you are being knocked off course, stick with it!

In my experience there is no perfect plan.

However you can choose the correct direction, undertake sensible planning and be effective with your efforts.


Giles Johnston
Author of Business Process Re-Engineering and creator of the 'Making It Happen' online course for improving continuous improvement skills.

P.S. If you want to read more about my story in 'On Time Delivery' click here.

Popular posts from this blog

Kamishibai Boards

Some tools are incredibly simple to use, and also deliver some amazing results. Kamishibai boards are a great example and are superb when you want some visual control over routine tasks. By the way Kamishibai is pronounced "come-e-she-bye" in case you were wondering!
As simple as you could want it, a Kamishibai board is a T-card system that has red cards glued to green
cards (so that each T-card has a red side and a green side). The red cards are for the incomplete tasks, where as the green cards symbolise that the work has been done. See the photo below of a board in use.
On the red side of the card you write the name of the task that needs to be completed, and if appropriate you can include details of how the task is to be completed. This is not expected to replace standard operating procedures, but can be a good opportunity for an aide memoire.
The boards can be organised for daily, weekly and even monthly cycles. They are great as part of a 5S implementation (the Susta…

Do You Put Enough Effort Into Changing How Your Business Works?

If you're reading this blog post it is a fair guess that you are looking to improve how your business works. So, what do you think about the question I have posed as the title of this article?
The reality is that if you could make a change happen with the same amount of effort that you current expend in your business changes would be happening left, right and centre. If you want to make a change stick in your business you need to increase your levels of effort temporarily. Without this increase in effort it is unlikely that the change you want will take place and sustain.
I recall when I worked as a Production Manager and the OTIF (On Time In Full) performance of our business was certainly not where it needed to be. For years the business had struggled to raise its level of performance; no additional effort had been expended. I planned out sixteen small improvement projects to address this and I got started with the changes. It was hard work at times and the work was on top of my…

Seeing the Improvement Wood for the Chaos Trees!

How are you feeling about your business the moment?

Are you feeling frustrated and irritated by the apparent lack of progress being made with your improvements?

If you answer ‘yes’ to this second question, don’t worry, you are not alone!

We all feel this way at times and the reason I am writing this article is that if you feel this way right now then I want to reassure you that there is a simple way to get out of this situation. I have been in this situation many times in both my operational life and as a consultant. It is normal and taking a deep breath and stepping back from the noise of the day-to-day is essential.

Let me take you through the three quick steps of Stopping, Assessing and Acting.


Take stock of where you are right now

In order for us to step back and try and see some of the ‘improvement wood’ as I refer to in the title of this article we need to have a simple question to focus our attention. A question I recommend that you ask is:

“Do our current processes suit the need…