Skip to main content

Are You Waiting For Perfection?

Over the past couple of weeks I have had numerous conversations with my clients about getting started with improvement activity, when a 'perfect' solution is still quite a long way off. Getting started is often one of the biggest hurdles when it comes to making process improvement changes within a business. Getting started anyway can bring with it several benefits.

I know that something that many of my clients share is a problem trying to get people together to undertake a new meeting format (such as a contract review process). Several of my clients in the past have had a similar issue regarding perfection. The system changes would take several months (aka 'perfection') but they could still create a manual process, that would be just as effective, and start it today. The manual version was slightly less efficient than the system version, but the habits of getting people together and doing the right things process wise were invaluable. When this happened in reality the businesses in question were truly ready for the updated system process, a great result in its own right let alone the fact that they had already been running an improved process for several months.

There are also some things that you just can't imagine or see prior to actually doing it. I would like to say that after years of running many successful business improvement projects that I know all of the obstacles, but I don't. A good example of this was when I was organising a handover process between functions at one of my client's businesses. Despite having done the research and reviewed the existing processes I was not prepared for the perceptions presented within the first handover meeting. I was also not prepared for the quirks in the business that never made it onto the process maps! So, what I thought (and my client's senior staff too) was perfection was in fact about 90% right. The feedback from this first session allowed me to make the necessary changes and perfection was then only a couple of further tweaks away.

Breaking improvements down into phases is another way to get away from the 'waiting for perfection' syndrome too. I know that when an improvement needs to be tackled it needs to be done in several phases, rather than jumping to the goal immediately. Whether you need to do something to buy some of your team some time to do the work, or there is a testing phase, the reality of most improvements is that they are a combination of steps combined with experimentation. Neither of these two elements lend themselves to reaching perfection immediately.

I'm not suggesting that we should settle for second best, or not try to implement a plan that doesn't look right. There have been lots of quotes about this very subject, one of my favourites being:

"You'll never be ready, so do it now anyway" (Unknown)

If your business is getting stuck with 'perfection' then maybe it is time to try 'fit for purpose' and see how that works out for you.



Giles Johnston
...optimising MRP systems and re-engineering business processes

....if you need a head start with your improvement plans.



Popular posts from this blog

Where there is a (performance) gap there is a concern

I had a really good day yesterday working with a client's team.

The team has issues. Plenty of issues. Some are managerial issues, some are people issues and some are production issues.

When I first met the team they didn't know what to do with their issues, so I started by helping them to see more issues.

Issues everywhere, they didn't seem very impressed.

And then we captured the issues as 'concerns' into the tried and tested 'concern cause countermeasure' format and followed the process:

Concerns probed for root causes and root causes converted into countermeasures.
Soon they realised that some of their root causes dealt with numerous concerns and they gained momentum.

Yesterday we pulled another one of their processes apart and identified all of the gaps. The gaps became concerns and we fed them back into the process. Now they have a practical action plan (of countermeasures) to upgrade the process in question.

What do you do with your performance gaps? …

Continuous Improvement and the Five Legged Race

Many improvement projects need the buy in of several people before they can progress. Amongst these people there will be some that have a firm view of what needs to happen and are keen to make progress. Some of the people won't be sure and they will need more time. Other people might not be that interested and have other priorities they want to focus on.

None of this is wrong.

It is an observation of mine and one that I see repeat on a regular basis with the businesses that I come into contact with.

But, if we take the principle from the observation we have an interesting improvement strategy (one that I personally use when I get stuck with my client's improvement projects).

You might have worked out the approach from the title of this blog post, but it is analogous to a three-legged race (or four, five, nine...). If someone in the group moves in the wrong direction and / or at the wrong speed then the whole group falls over.


In the example I gave at the start it is no differe…

Do you have time to prepare (in order to become super productive)?

I had a funny conversation a few weeks ago with a team that was complaining about one of their colleagues spending 'ages' preparing their workstation within their factory. I meet a lot of people that spend too long preparing (and effectively procrastinating) so I was intrigued by their comment. It turns out that this individual didn't spend too long but rather his colleagues dived into their work without thinking through what the best way to work was...

The slower to start gentleman did in fact prepare his work area. He was also able to produce a far greater amount of work in the same time period because he had invested in a smarter way of working than his counterparts. The time spent preparing his working area was valuable and not overdone.

This example reminds us of the importance of the second S in 5S (set in order) and how workstation design is critical if we want to maximise the productivity of our teams. Whether this is a physical work area in a factory, the filing s…