Skip to main content

If your improvement is fundamentally right – stick to your guns!



Discussions around improvements are really interesting. There will always be some people who are in favour of an idea, some who are opposed and some that don’t really mind either way. When an improvement makes sense to the majority of people around the table it usually gets traction and things happen. When enough people aren’t sure about the merits of an improvement it can be easy for the idea to be killed off. However, changing the way that we present our ideas can bring about a completely different outcome.

If the idea is fundamentally sound, if the principle behind the idea is good, then the improvement is worth fighting for. What I don’t think we should do is get hung up on is the ‘style’ of the improvement when our idea is shouted down. When we bring a solution to the table it doesn’t mean that everyone will understand it. When we talk about the improvement principle and then the solution, the context can help others to get onboard with the solution a lot more easily.

If you haven’t developed a solution yet, looking at an improvement from a position of its principle can help you to get a lot more creative and generate alternative ideas as to how you can implement the improvement. This is like using the 5 Why method to identify a true root cause to a business issue, so that you can develop a really powerful change for how your business works. The principle is the generic, fundamental, fact or truth behind your idea. This is what we want; the way that it gets implemented is a matter of choice, ease or style.

For every improvement principle that you want to implement there will be lots of different ways that you can approach it. Presenting a finished solution to your colleagues might get you the response I mentioned above, but bringing a principle and a potential implementation approach (with the opportunity to generate alternatives) might get a completely different reception.

I remember the Assembly Team Leader at a factory I used to work at locking the doors to the Assembly Shop because he didn’t like one of my ideas. He disliked it so much that he stopped production of the entire business and tried to march me up to the European CEO’s office (we didn’t get there, after a lot of huffing and puffing from the Team Leader!). After he had calmed down we were able to talk about the principle behind the idea (I hadn’t even tried to implement it at this stage!) and we were able to re-work the idea; a minor tweak and the idea (in his eyes) was palatable.

It would have been easy to walk away from this improvement, to back down from the aggressive reaction, but the principle behind the idea was sound. The actual improvement that we did implement dropped over 20% from the lead time of the product line in question (large, heavy, bespoke products) and cost nothing to implement, other than a couple of hours of our time. The improvement could have been lost very easily if I hadn’t persevered.

If you find yourself in a similar position, with your ideas being under attack on a regular basis, then try stepping back and identifying the improvement principle behind your idea. With this in hand, try the conversation again and see if you can come to an agreement as to how this improvement can be implemented.

It is always a shame when a good idea is dismissed unnecessarily, whether this is out of fear, ignorance or something else. Let’s see if we can increase our hit rate and implement more of our great ideas!


Giles


About the author Giles Johnston is a Chartered Engineer who specialises in helping businesses to grow and improve through better business processes. Giles is also the author of Business Process Re-Engineering and creator of the 'Making It Happen' continuous improvement toolkit.

Discover practical improvement strategies to drive up productivity for both you and your business. Access the free tools section today by clicking here.

Popular posts from this blog

Kamishibai Boards

Available to purchase here. Some tools are incredibly simple to use, and also deliver some amazing results. Kamishibai boards are a great example and are superb when you want some visual control over routine tasks. By the way Kamishibai is pronounced "come-e-she-bye" in case you were wondering! As simple as you could want it, a Kamishibai board is a T-card system that has red cards glued to green cards (so that each T-card has a red side and a green side). The red cards are for the incomplete tasks, where as the green cards symbolise that the work has been done. See the photo below of a board in use. On the red side of the card you write the name of the task that needs to be completed, and if appropriate you can include details of how the task is to be completed. This is not expected to replace standard operating procedures, but can be a good opportunity for an aide memoire. The boards can be organised for daily, weekly and even monthly cycles. They are g

Kamishibai Boards: A Visual Management Tool to Improve Discipline and Workplace Habits

If you need to increase your effectiveness in the workplace and need a visual tool to help with day to day task management then this short guide is for you. Giles Johnston, a business improvement consultant for small to medium sized businesses, takes you through the steps needed to implement a low / no cost solution to your day to day management problems - a 'Kamishibai' board.  A Kamishibai board can help to improve discipline within the workplace and ensure that the working days / weeks / months are more effective. Common within businesses that use 'lean' methods to improve efficiency and performance (and very effective to use when implementing 5S), a Kamishibai board can be used in its own right, in any kind of business, whether you are going through a lean transformation or not.  Click here to view on Amazon.com. Smartspeed Consulting Limited Taking the frustration out of on time delivery.

What is 5S and how does it help to improve the performance of my business?

Many businesses have heard of 5S; it is a simple workplace organisation system that is designed to make workplaces more effective and more efficient, as well as safer. Many businesses also try and fail at implementing 5S . It might be simple, but as you will know, anything that involves changing the behaviours of your staff isn’t always straightforward. If you haven’t heard of 5S before there are five basic steps, all beginning with ‘S’. They are: Sort – clearing out the clutter and re-distributing other people’s belongings. Set in order – optimising the workplace so that everything you need frequently is close at hand. Shine – cleaning the workplace to an appropriate level. Standards – defining what good looks like and how you will keep it that way. Sustain – forming the habits to retain the benefits of an organised and disciplined workplace. So, how does 5S improve the performance of your business? From a safety perspective, fewer accidents means less downtime.